Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group

Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group

Whisky: Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group

Country/Region: Scotland/Islands

ABV: 56.2%

Cask: Hogshead

Age: 13 Years (Distilled 7 May 2005, Bottled 9 Aug. 2018)


Nose: A touch of herbal menthol and malty biscuits, sea salt and roasted sesame, slightly acrid tobacco and tar, ash, catnip, and citrus rind.

Palate: Medium-bodied and mellow, tart citrus, salt, tobacco, fruit punch, motor oil, salt, herbal smoke and linoleum at the end.

Finish: The finish was medium-length with orange and citrus rind, tobacco ash, and menthol.


Score: 5-6

Mental Image: 24H Diner Experience

Narrative & Notes: Stepping back in time to a 1980s diner in which everything was infused with the sweet, acrid smell of menthol cigarettes and ash. The cigarette vending machine used to sit right inside our local dinner; the aroma led me further into malty pie crust, citrusy meringue, sesame crackers, herbal catnip, used ashtrays, and more acrid tobacco. Medium-bodied with a mellow oily quality, the flavor profile began with a lovely tart grapefruit that opened up with more blood orange and key lime before salt, menthol, and subtle tobacco emerged. A delicate fruit punch ran alongside motor oil, salt, and linoleum, which gradually faded as dried grass and herbal tobacco lingered to the end. The finish was medium-length with orange and citrus rind, tobacco ash, and menthol.

I have never had a whisky strike me with such a strong menthol cigarette vibe before. While there was a profoundly nostalgic element, I was not entirely seduced by the memory of ashtrays and smoke-soaked clothing. In fact, those memories are best left behind— if only the whisky reminded me more of pie and hot chocolate, I would feel differently.

Overall, an intriguing whisky, most likely Highland Park though one that was a bit different from the standard fare of citrus and steamships. I tend to be a bit lukewarm on Orkney malts, so if they suit your fancy, you may find this more to your taste than I did.

Image Credit: Whiskybase

Highland Park 17 Year (1999), Abbey Whisky “Anon Batch 2”

Highland Park 17 Year (1999), Abbey Whisky “Anon Batch 2”

Highland Park 21 Year (1998), The Whisky Jury "Eye Land Pork"

Highland Park 21 Year (1998), The Whisky Jury "Eye Land Pork"