Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Highland Park 17 Year (1999), Abbey Whisky “Anon Batch 2”

Highland Park 17 Year (1999), Abbey Whisky “Anon Batch 2”

Whisky: Highland Park 17 Year (1999), Abbey Whisky “Anon Batch 2”

Country/Region: Scotland/Orkney

ABV: 53.8%

Cask: Refill Sherry Butt

Age: 17 Years (Distilled 1999, Bottled 2017)


Nose: Coastal and maritime, salt, mineral, orange citrus, mild charcoal smoke; hints of tobacco, leather, and dried kelp.

Palate: Medium-bodied, maritime and citrusy, orange, a hint of coconut, leather, driftwood, charcoal, musty tobacco, peppery.

Finish: Medium-length, peppery and a touch spirited with citrus, minerals, and a kiss of smoke.


Score: 7

Mental Image: Maritime Meandering

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was pleasantly coastal, with a maritime brine washing up on a mineral-rich beach with scattered bits of driftwood and tar. Orange and tangerine provided a citrusy backbone with hints of herbal thyme and mint. A mild charcoal smoke and ash blew in with hints of tobacco, leather, moss, and dried kelp as the aroma continued moving down the shoreline. Medium-bodied, the flavor profile popped with salt and citrus as if I liked the salted rim of a tropical, citrusy margarita with orange, tangerine, and hints of coconut. Leather, driftwood, and charcoal lingered further in the background with a musty tobacco and slightly acrid smoke. Medium-length, the finish was peppery and a touch spirited with citrus, mineral, and a kiss of smoke.

I have a fairly mixed relationship with Highland Park; there have been some highs but lots of middling scores and a few absolute lows. I mention this because I had few expectations when I finally got around to trying this dram; I figured it might be a pretty typical Orkney malt and quickly forgotten. I was wrong, clearly. Maybe low expectations are not always bad, though; the less one expects from a whisky, the easier it is to be impressed.

The flavors were pretty typical for the distillery— I have described numerous Highland Park as being some combination of tropical margarita and fruity sangria with a maritime aesthetic. Peatier malts can lean more toward coal and an acrid industrial quality, however, this had only a whiff of those elements as the refill sherry maturation elevated the fruitier elements with a hint of leather. I particularly enjoyed the very clean and subtly tropical elements.

Overall, an Orkney delight, this is the kind of Highland Park I really enjoy. For anyone wondering how you can know for sure it is a Highland Park, consider checking out the handy coordinates on the bottle!

Mortlach 19 Year (2001), SMWS 76.149 “Flavour maze”

Mortlach 19 Year (2001), SMWS 76.149 “Flavour maze”

Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group

Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group