Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Highland Park 21 Year (1998), The Whisky Jury "Eye Land Pork"

Highland Park 21 Year (1998), The Whisky Jury "Eye Land Pork"

Whisky: Highland Park 21 Year (1998), The Whisky Jury "Eye Land Pork"

Country/Region: Scotland/Islands

ABV: 48.3%

Cask: Refill Hogshead

Age: 21 Years (Distilled April 1998, Bottled Sept. 2019)


Nose: Citrus, fennel, rose hip oil, maritime, finished pinewood, herbal and medicinal, dried mint, a touch of motor oil and heather.

Palate: Medium to light-bodied, gentle, maritime, heather, driftwood, slightly waxy citrus, mint, subtle medicinal herbs.

Finish: Medium to long with mint, salt, and subtle citrus.


Score: 6-7

Mental Image: Medicinal Milkshakes

Narrative & Notes:  The aroma landed me somewhere between a cozy ski lodge and a musty traditional Chinese medicine shop as cured citrus, finished pinewood, fennel, rose hip, mugwort, dried mint, and an array of herbal medicinal notes wafted out of the glass. A subtle maritime salt carried on with hints of motor oil and dry heather. Medium to light-bodied, gentle, and buttery, the flavor profile opened with a salty sea breeze and dried heather— a walk along the beach to admire driftwood and saltwater ponds. An almost waxy lemon citrus developed at the end with mint, melon rind, and teases of the medicinal herbs from the nose. The finish was medium to long with mint, salt, and subtle citrus.

A restrained and quiet dram, this Highland Park leaned more toward dried grass and herbs than fruit and sea— though all those elements were still present to one degree. I found this a tad light for my taste, though the finish had good staying power as the mint and citrus lingered pleasantly between sips.

I do not typically look up other reviews on something until I have posted my own; however, as my notes slightly differed from what I expected, I skimmed Whiskybase and a few different sites. While many of my notes match those I found, it seemed other reviewers picked out more fruit and less of those herbal notes than I did. So your mileage may vary; I thought this was an intriguing Highland Park and a bit different from the norm.

Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group

Unnamed Orkney 13 Year (2005), Signatory Vintage Cask DRU 17A/63#72 for The Winebow Group

Orkney 11 Year (2011), Thompson Brothers

Orkney 11 Year (2011), Thompson Brothers