Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Blair Athol 14 Year (2007), SMWS 68.88 "Living happily ever after"

Blair Athol 14 Year (2007), SMWS 68.88 "Living happily ever after"

Whisky: Blair Athol 14 Year (2007), SMWS 68.88 "Living happily ever after"

Country/Region: Scotland/Highland

ABV: 53.3%

Cask: Hogshead (11Y), First Fill STR PX Sherry Barrique

Age: 14 Years (Distilled 5 Oct. 2007)


Nose: Big fruits and chocolate with a touch of spice and mossy stones; cherries and plums resting in syrup-filled candy jars, dried and salted stone fruits on the side with li hing mui and anise; chocolate bonbons with a touch of strawberry and wood lacquer.

Palate: Medium-bodied, salted plums and dried fruits, li hing mui over cherries and candied orange peel, licorice and anise, root beer flavored syrup, a touch of butter and maltier pastries— rum cakes and black sugar buns; wood and a touch of herbal tobacco toward the end.

Finish: Medium to long with brown sugar, malty pastry, and citrus.


Score: 7 (82)

Mental Image: Wooden “Do Not Lick the Jar” Sign

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was big, loud, and gregarious, with massive jars of fruits and candies displayed in an old-fashioned Crackseed store— a type of Chinese candy store common in old Hawaii. Plums, cherries, rock sugar, li hing mui, strawberry, and anise wafted in with a touch of wood lacquer and mossy stones. The final sherry maturation expressed itself clearly, elevating the fruitier elements of the malt and giving them a lovely candied spice. The palate featured much the same, with the cask pushing everything toward candies fruit with a dazzling sprinkle of li hing mui, orange, and sweet concentrated root beer flavored syrup. A touch spirited and spicy at times, water cooled it off easily and brought more cola to the fore. The flavors were familiar, well-structured, and fairly balanced if perhaps a touch sweet for my taste. The finish was medium to long with brown sugar buns, candied citrus, and oak.

Overall, not a subtle whisky! This kind of big cask affair is not really to my taste, but there was enough going on here to keep me interested and a bit of water helped break up some of the woody tannins and bright spirit.

Orkney 9 Year, Jack's Pirate Whisky Überfahrt nach Sachsen Part I Cask 108

Orkney 9 Year, Jack's Pirate Whisky Überfahrt nach Sachsen Part I Cask 108

Blair Athol 13 Year (2009), Douglas Laing Cask DL16767 for K&L

Blair Athol 13 Year (2009), Douglas Laing Cask DL16767 for K&L