Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Clynelish 17 Year (1998), Signatory Vintage Cask 7774

Clynelish 17 Year (1998), Signatory Vintage Cask 7774

Whisky: Clynelish 17 Year (1998), Signatory Vintage Cask 7774

Country/Region: Scotland/Highland

ABV: 43%

Cask: Hogshead

Age: 17 Years (Distilled 27 May 1998, Bottled 27 July 2015)


Nose: Citrusy and a touch waxy, hints of cream and salt, tropical fruits and shortbread, pine, swimming pools.

Palate: Light-bodied and austere at first, citrusy with herbal and salty undercurrents, malt pastries, peppery mineral water, paraffin candies, beaches and swimming pools.

Finish: Medium-length and citrusy with beechwood and a touch of ocean.


Score: 6-7 (80)

Mental Image: Swimming Pools and Beach Umbrellas

Narrative & Notes: Pleasantly citrusy with lemon zest and waxy rinds, a bit of orange bumped in with a touch of cream and salt lingering in the background. Hints of melon and pineapple shortbread cakes developed between citrusy cream sodas, pine trees, and summer swimming pools spritzed with chlorine. Light-bodied, the flavor profile was austere with citrusy lemon and orange zest ahead of herbal and salt undercurrents.  A rosemary scone appeared from herbal and malty notions until another wave of peppery mineral water washed in paraffin candies. Beachy and summery with swimming pools and melted popsicles— it was all very mellow and relaxed. Medium-length with citrusy, beechwood, and a touch of ocean.

Mellow vibes were all around with this excellent late 90s Clynelish. I picked up a couple bottles it earlier in 2024 and wasted no time opening one up to share with friends— it did not survive the summer. It was only a shadow of the magical and wonderfully waxy Clynelish of the era— a whisky that fires the imagination of many a whisky drinker— but it never pretended to be. The flavors were well-balanced and soothing, if not a touch too austere on the palate at times. The effect was a perfect fit for a summer time pool-side whisky.

Overall, grab an inflatable raft and mellow out.

Clynelish 21 Year (2000), Berry Bros & Rudd “Sutherland” Cask 1432

Clynelish 21 Year (2000), Berry Bros & Rudd “Sutherland” Cask 1432

Clynelish 16 Year (2007), Gordon & MacPhail Cask 311259 for K&L

Clynelish 16 Year (2007), Gordon & MacPhail Cask 311259 for K&L