Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Ailsa Bay 10 Year “Aerstone Land Cask”

Ailsa Bay 10 Year “Aerstone Land Cask”

Whisky: Ailsa Bay 10 Year “Aerstone Land Cask”

Country/Region: Scotland/Lowland

ABV: 40%

Cask: Oak

Age: 10 Years (Bottled 2018)


Nose: Smoked oily fish and caramelized teriyaki sauce, hints of pineapple on the grill with burning pine, hints of more medicinal herbs, rubber sole leather shoes and cigar box lent a classy vibe.

Palate: Light body, soft smoke with burning pine wood, hints of cordite and camphor, grilled peaches, subtle tobacco and herbs, essence of smoked fish with hints of lemon.

Finish: Medium-length finish with toasted herbs and old fireworks.


Score: 4-5

Mental Image: 2 AM Party Clean Up

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was beautiful, and the flavor profile featured some nice complexity. I would have scored this a bit higher if it were not so light on the palate. The whisky felt lighter or more watery the more I drank it— there was no crescendo to something fuller or oilier; instead, it all felt more washed out over time. The finish remained lovely, and I appreciated how long it clung to the palate, which was a surprise due to the tiptoeing nature of the palate.

I initially tasted this blind and thought it reminded me of a sherried Kilchoman at maybe 43-46%; I have had a few malts from that Islay distillery with a beautifully complex aroma but a washed-out palate. Looking at the list of possibilities my buddy provided, I am not sure anything sounds right. Maybe Glenglassaugh or Kemet? However, I cannot imagine either of those having quite this type of smoke.

Wrong again! I totally forgot about Ailsa Bay, the malt distillery hidden inside Girvan. This was only my second Ailsa Bay, so maybe I can be forgiven for forgetting it exists, perhaps even more so since this was under the Aerstone 10-Year Land Cask label.

Honestly, I am impressed. Maybe the score doesn’t seem that way, but I enjoyed the aroma and the long finish. If the flavors and mouthfeel were just dialed up a little bit further, this would have been an absolute delight.

Auchentoshan 21 Year (1983), Scott's Selection

Auchentoshan 21 Year (1983), Scott's Selection

Glenkinchie 20 Year (1990), Diageo Special Release 2010

Glenkinchie 20 Year (1990), Diageo Special Release 2010