Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 28 Year (1993), WhiskySponge No. 53

Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 28 Year (1993), WhiskySponge No. 53

Whisky: Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 28 Year (1993), WhiskySponge No. 53

Country/Region: Scotland/Highland

ABV: 50.7%

Cask: Refill Hogshead

Age: 28 Year (Distilled 1993, Bottled 2022)


Nose: Musty tropical fruits, mountain guava, lychee and rambutan with pits, tangerine, tangy green tomato, black vinegar, woody antique furniture

Palate: Medium-bodied musty tropical fruit and antique lace, citrus, hints of butter and cream, wood, dried palm fronds, roasted barley tea, hints of chocolate, chicory, and white pepper.

Finish: Medium-length and drying with subtle tropical fruit, earth, and spice.


Score: 7-8

Mental Image: Backyard Carport Foraging

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was initially quite fruity with lovely overripe mountain guava fallen along a hiking trail, fleshy lychee and rambutan with their woody pits, and a sweet, slightly diluted, tangerine soda. As the fruit took on more wood and a lively tanginess, I found green tomatoes, musty black vinegar, and caramel alongside dusty wooden antique furniture. Medium-bodied, the flavor profile closely mirrored the nose with a touch more mustiness to the fruit and wood. Mountain guava and lychee provided a tropical zip with musty antique lace with hints of lemon and lavender. A mild butter and cream developed on the mid-palate with earth, finished wood, dried palm fronds, and roasted barley tea. Hints of cocoa powder, chicory, and white pepper lingered at the end, with the cocoa more prevalent after a few drops of water. The finish was medium-length and drying with subtle tropical fruit, earth, and spice.

Not a boring whisky! Few of the flavors here were exceptionally straightforward and it sometimes felt as though everything hit at the same time. I thought this was a lot of fun to pick through and sip on while slowly trying to identify some reference points to what I was tasting. I enjoyed returning to this whisky as my impression improved each time I sat with it. Some of the woodiness I initially found a bit off-putting fell further into the background, relegated to the finish with some slightly astringent barley tea, while tropical fruits and an earthy mustiness came to the fore.

Overall, a complex affair with a relatively demanding whisky.

Loch Lomond Old Rhosdhu 29 Year (1993), WhiskySponge No. 67

Loch Lomond Old Rhosdhu 29 Year (1993), WhiskySponge No. 67

Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 11 Year (2007), SMWS 112.47 “Have some Madeira my dear”

Loch Lomond Inchmurrin 11 Year (2007), SMWS 112.47 “Have some Madeira my dear”