Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Longmorn 17 Year (2003), SMWS 7.264 “Seventh heaven”

Longmorn 17 Year (2003), SMWS 7.264 “Seventh heaven”

Whisky: Longmorn 17 Year (2003), SMWS 7.264 “Seventh heaven”

Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside

ABV: 55.8%

Cask: First Fill Bourbon

Age: 17 Years (17 Nov. 2003)


Nose: Tropical fruits, kiwi and guava candies, coconut oil, lotion, mint, hints of lemongrass and ginger, a kiss of salt, and an occasional touch of spirit.

Palate: Medium-bodied, tropical fruit syrups, guava, vanilla, coconut ice cream, kiwi candies, slightly grassy, cured oak, hints of salted, pickled plum, li hing mui, at the end.

Finish: Medium-length and slightly drying with oak, tropical fruit, and subtle creamy lotion.


Score: 7

Mental Image: Shave Ice Shop Specials Board

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was beautifully tropical, with a kiss of spirited prickle as it developed. Lovely tropical mango, lychee, and hints of pineapple paired with sweet, tangy kiwi and guava candies. Coconut arrived with a subtle cream and gave the impression of coconut oil or lotion with hints of lemon grass, ginger, and mint. A kiss of salt popped on occasion with woody cured bamboo. Medium-bodied, the flavor profile closely mirrored the aroma with guava, lychee, pineapple, and vanilla syrups leading to coconut ice cream. Kiwi and guava candies lingered on the mid-palate with subtle grass, oak, and cured bamboo. Waiting at the end was a tickle of spirit and li hing mui powder, salted pickled plum. The finish was medium-length and slightly drying with wood, tropical fruits, and creamy coconut lotion.

I love a good tropical Longmorn, and this was bursting with tropical fruits. I only wish the spirit felt a bit more refined and weighty on the palate; the spirited prickle was not overly distracting, but it gave the impression of a whisky that was somehow incomplete or a bit rough around the edges. A good buddy also had a bottle of this and added a stave of mizunara oak to it; after a good six months in his freezer (to presumably slow down the wood interactions), I thought the malt had improved quite a bit, the flavors felt thicker and the mouthfeel more balanced.

Overall, this was good, certainly a few rungs better than average, but not quite extraordinary. It felt like it was on the road to greatness, though, so I hope SMWS has held back some of the sibling casks for further maturation, maybe even a few years finished in a second-fill wine cask of some kind. I rarely say to myself, this whisky could use some time in another cask, but here we are.

Arran 17 Year (1999), Cadenhead's

Arran 17 Year (1999), Cadenhead's

April 2023 Digest

April 2023 Digest