Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Kilchoman 6 Year (2015) 100% Islay for Warehouse Liquors

Kilchoman 6 Year (2015) 100% Islay for Warehouse Liquors

Whisky: Kilchoman 6 Year (2015) 100% Islay for Warehouse Liquors

Country/Region: Scotland/Islay

ABV: 57.4%

Cask: PX Sherry Cask

Age: 6 Years (Distilled 27 May 2015, Bottled 27 May 2021)

Nose: Smoked meats, nuts, and spice. A velvety sweet smoke infused everything— smoked honey cured ham, oysters, rosemary, and kippers. A holiday roasting pan of charred parsnips, thyme, sage, and black pepper— all we needed was the leg of lamb. A nutty richness appeared with time, as honey-roasted peanuts and roasted pecans came to mind with a hint of maple.

Palate: Full-bodied with spice, tobacco, and caramel. Thick and oily, a sweet smoke of smoldering pine and eucalyptus married with mellow herbal tobacco and a roasting pan full of peppercorns, star anise, rosemary, and fennel bulbs. Brown sugar and caramel brought to mind banana’s foster and fruity desserts flambéed table-side. The wife found it was sweet and dessert-like with roasted peanut and boot polish.

Finish: Long and lingering notes of sweet candied smoke.


Score: 7

Mental Image: Holiday Smoke Out


Notes: The market for single cask Kilchoman seems to have jumped up a couple of price points in the last year or two. At the beginning of the tit-for-tat tariff war, distillery representatives interviewed on Whiskycask explained how they planned to split part of the tariff expense along with their American importer ImPex. At least for a time, the price of their single cask bottles appeared to hold steady— it was already a bit high, but the quality was often top-notch, and few other distilleries offer a similar single cask program. The dam seems to have broken— for Kilchoma and the rest of the market— bottles that once sat in the $120-130 range now are fifty dollars more expensive.

This was one of the better single cask Kilchoman I have had the privilege to try. It was sweet and meaty on the nose with a beautiful layer of spice that carried through to the palate. More dessert than bbq, the cask played a decisive role in elevating the underlying sweetness of the 100% Islay malt. The finish was ridiculously long and settled across the palate with a sweet, velvety smoke.

Overall, the price of single cask Kilchoman has increased, but casks like this remain worth the occasional splurge.

Glen Elgin 17 Year (2004), Lady of the Glen

Glen Elgin 17 Year (2004), Lady of the Glen

Braeval 17 Year (1998), Hart Brothers

Braeval 17 Year (1998), Hart Brothers