Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Dalmore 12 Year (2008), Gordon & MacPhail for Broken Barrel Club

Dalmore 12 Year (2008), Gordon & MacPhail for Broken Barrel Club

Whisky: Dalmore 12 Year (2008), Gordon & MacPhail for Broken Barrel Club

Country/Region: Scotland/Highland

ABV: 57.3%

Cask: Refill Bourbon Barrel

Age: 12 Years (Distilled 2008, Bottled 10 Mar. 2021)

Nose: Honey, malt, and tropical fruit syrup. Thick and gooey honey with hints of sesame and pistachio pastries carried forth with rich malty sugars. A bit of spirited heat poked out between notes of vanilla, tropical fruit syrup, and pineapple upside-down cake.

Palate: Medium-bodied and buttery with notes of caramel, orchard fruit, and honey. Velvety caramel and butterscotch with green apples, orange rind, and a kiss of salt. Caramel apples shifted to honey-coated pears while a slightly creamy nougat and black pepper developed on the back end.

Finish: Medium-length malty sugars and honey.


Score: 5

Mental Image: Caramel Apple Pie


Notes: A slightly off-character Dalmore, this reminded me more of Balvenie or Glenmorangie than anything else. There was a hint of the coastal undercurrents, tobacco, or orange zest I associate with the distillery. Instead, orchard fruits and caramel dominated much of the experience. No doubt the casking played a role here— it had a minimal influence on the malt compared to the typical distillery style. Dalmore matures most of its whisky in first-fill bourbon barrels or oloroso sherry— finishing many of its core products in sherry butts, according to Michael Jackson’s Malt Whisky Companion.

A good friend selected this cask, so  I am hardly a neutral party in this review. However, I am not sure if I judged the whisky more severely or gave it a bit of a pass. It was an interesting Dalmore, especially for anyone whose experience has been chiefly with the sherry forward core bottles. Yet, I am not a fan of orchard fruit-centric profiles, especially when the accompanying notes are caramel or butterscotch. This Dalmore was on the simple side, and orchard fruits played a starring role without much to back them up.

Overall, a wonderfully promising aroma let me down a bit on the palate. There were no apparent flaws to the whisky, but neither were there many exciting elements. A fine sipper to share with friends and a dram perhaps of interest to those who have enjoyed Dalmore’s core products.

Benromach 43 Year (1975)

Benromach 43 Year (1975)

Tormore 28 Year (1988), Antique Lions of Spirits “The Birds”

Tormore 28 Year (1988), Antique Lions of Spirits “The Birds”