Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Ardmore 12 Year (2009), Little Brown Dog Spirits

Ardmore 12 Year (2009), Little Brown Dog Spirits

Whisky: Ardmore 12 Year (2009), Little Brown Dog Spirits

Country/Region: Scotland/Highland

ABV: 55.5%

Cask: PX Sherry Finish (1Y)

Age: 12 Years (Distilled 26 Nov. 2009, Bottled 3 May 2022)


Nose: Flower garden beds, floral-earthy, dark chocolate, hints of caramel and nougat, graham crackers, thistle, walnut and oak, musty herbal notes with more time.

Palate: Medium-bodied, slightly oily, woody, earthy, and herbal. Graham crackers, chocolate roasted barley, polished rosewood, earthy garden bed, thistle, thyme, and somewhat bitter herbal notes at the end.

Finish: Long and lingering with oak, earth, and garden herbs.


Score: 7

Mental Image: Mouse Bakeoff in the Holly Bush

Narrative & Notes: I poured this as dram #18 on a “Holiday Mystery Whisky Advent Calendar” and guessed it was a late teen mystery/unknown Highland whisky. My guess was a bit of a cop-out; after eighteen days of mystery whiskies, I admit I have a bit of fatigue with guessing. I do not usually do a lot of blind samples because I do not find them reflective of how I experience whisky. Branding, storytelling, and packaging play at least some role in how we perceive and experience a dram, even if we do not precisely taste them in the glass. My wife prefers them blind— so I am always glad I have her to balance me out.

I thought this was nice— it was earthy and savory with slightly bitter chocolate and herbal notes. The dram left me recalling the flowerbeds and holly bushes where I grew up, which had the ideal little passageways between the roots for cats, rabbits, and mice. I never saw a mouse there, but I pictured them using the open spaces between the bases to host a baking competition, especially as I picked up graham cracker crust that appeared on the nose and palate.

Overall, not bad. It turned out this was a thirteen-year-old Ardmore with a PX sherry finish; I got only the barest whiffs of smoke on the whisky, but that is not too unusual; Ardmore can vary from subtle to aggressive at almost any age. I was surprised I did not pick up a significant PX influence considering the finish, though I suspect it contributed to the wood and chocolate elements.

Image Credit: Little Brown Dog Spirits

Ledaig “Unpeated” 26 Year (1995), Thompson Brothers

Ledaig “Unpeated” 26 Year (1995), Thompson Brothers

“Secret Grain Distillery” 47 Year (1973), Nectar of the Daily Drams

“Secret Grain Distillery” 47 Year (1973), Nectar of the Daily Drams