Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Glenfarclas 9 Year, Dramfool “Glenmarvellous”

Glenfarclas 9 Year, Dramfool “Glenmarvellous”

Whisky : Glenfarclas 9 Year, Dramfool “Glenmarvellous”

Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside

ABV : 58.3%

Cask : Oloroso Sherry Barrel

Age : 9 Years (Distilled 23 Nov. 2011, 22 March 2021)

Nose : Chocolate, caramel, and fruit.  Notions of chocolate caramels, chocolate-covered cantaloupe, Fudgesicle bars, and espresso ice cream interspersed with grapefruit and pomegranate seeds.  The unctuous aroma was almost effervescent at times with impressions of hot cocoa and marshmallows.  A few drops of water brought out more tobacco, dried fruit, and espresso.

Palate : Full-bodied and oily with stewed stone fruit, pastries, and chocolate.  Syrupy stewed dates, figs, and prunes over warm sticky buns with chopped walnuts.  Chocolate undercurrents rose on the mid-palate with cocoa and cinnamon hot chocolate.  Hints of bitter orange, grapefruit, and cherries appeared around the edges, while peach upside-down cake with gooey caramelized stone fruit came to mind.  At the end was a sweet rich cola note that lingered on the palate.

Finish : Lingering cola and spiked hot chocolate.


Score : 8

Mental Image : Backyard Dessert: Hot Chocolate and Grilled Peaches


Notes :  If Glenfarclas were like this more often, I would count myself among the distillery’s fandom. This Dramfool “Glenmarvellous” was unbelievable; it was incredibly complex and remarkably easy to drink after less than a decade in a first-fill Oloroso sherry barrel. It stood as proof of the saying that age is just a number and that you should never judge a dram only off the number of years it spent tucked away in some shed, warehouse, or semi-industrial lot.

I first tried a blind sample of the Glenmarvellous in Marsh 2021 during an online tasting with Bruce from Dramfool. The tasting featured a set of six blind drams, including a PX sister cask to this, a Lochindaal, and a pair of elderly teenage Port Charlotte. This Glenfarclas was just about the unanimous choice for best of the evening (the Lochindaal had a couple of votes, too), and I absolutely could not believe it was Glenfarclas after the reveal.

Fast forward six months, and I ended up with a bottle. I could not wait to try it again to see if my initial impression still stood the test of time. It did. In fact, this was even better than I remembered. Overall, I do not often find a sherry-driven dram that I love, so I was thrilled with this bottle. The cocoa notes gave a through-line from the nose to the palate, while sweet caramelized fruits, pastries, and cola gave distinct layers to the flavor profile.

Bladnoch 25 Year (1993), Signatory Vintage 30th Anniversary

Bladnoch 25 Year (1993), Signatory Vintage 30th Anniversary

Liber 14 Year (2006), Spanish Whisky Club

Liber 14 Year (2006), Spanish Whisky Club