Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

MacDuff 12 Year SMWS 6.34 “Boundless intemperance”

MacDuff 12 Year SMWS 6.34 “Boundless intemperance”

Whisky : MacDuff 12 Year SMWS 6.34 “Boundless intemperance”

Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside

ABV : 58.6%

Cask : Refill Ex-bourbon Hogshead

Age : 12 Years (Distilled 29 Aug. 2006)

Nose : Subtle aroma of tropical flower beds, mellow fruits, and creamy starch.  Opens up with layers of lemon custard, citrusy gummy bears, bamboo baskets, melon, and berries.  

Palate : Medium body with a mellow flavor profile and nice structure.  Creamy nutty almond milk, apple juice, and honey-lemon drops.  Sugary pastries decorated with ripe berries and tropical fruit curd.  Floral notes come on the end along with a tannic dryness almost like raw almonds.

Finish : Medium length finish that gradually lengthens; pastries, honey, jelly.


Score : 6

Mental Image : Bake Sale Guava Bars

Something Better : Westland Reverie Fig. 1 (similar fruit curd/pastry, more tropical, longer finish)

Something Similar : Michel Couvreur Overaged (similar almond/pastries, less sharp fruit)


Notes : A simple Speyside with a pleasant profile.  Probably not a lot more to say about this MacDuff.  It was nice, but not really the kind of flavor profile to which I gravitate.  There was nothing particularly distinct about it, it was a fine easy sipper that showcased a fruity malt without getting lost in any heavy cask influence.  It felt a bit young as it definitely had a spirited quality, though considering it already had good tannic structure and body, I am not sure more time in the cask would have been to its benefit.  

It is the kind of dram I reach for on a warm summer evening when I just want something I do not need to think about a whole lot.  If you like simple fruity Speyside drams, then this would be right up your alley.

Cragganmore 12 Year, 2019 Special Release

Cragganmore 12 Year, 2019 Special Release

Balvenie 14 Year “Peat Week” 2018 Edition

Balvenie 14 Year “Peat Week” 2018 Edition