Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Glen Scotia 7 Year SMWS 93.137 “As usual: unusual”

Glen Scotia 7 Year SMWS 93.137 “As usual: unusual”

Whisky : Glen Scotia 7 Year SMWS 93.137 “As usual: unusual”

Country/Region : Scotland/Campbeltown

ABV : 59.7%

Cask : First Fill Ex-Bourbon

Age : 7 Years (Distilled 9 Feb. 2012)

Nose : Tart creamy fruits and subtle spices.  Unripened starchy tropical fruits, green pineapple, tart lemon curd, and stewed rhubarb.  Funk and cream came through as over-ripened bananas and white pepper gravy.  Faint barbecue and charcoal linger in the background with old charred salmon cedar plank.

Palate : Creamy and mouth coating, initially sweet, it quickly transitioned toward blue cheese funk and salty brine.  Fresh cheese and herbs, apricot marmalade, sunrise papaya, cherimoya, and full cream yogurt.  A few drops of water brought out more tannic dryness, bitter herbs, and spice.  A few more drops of water toned down some of the bitter notes and brought forward earthy ginger and a spicy sarsaparilla root beer bite.

Finish :  Lingering dryness with earthy notes and faint ash.


Score : 5

Mental Image : Fresh Cheese & Fruit Farm Breakfast


Notes :  I loved this, then hated it, then loved it again— each time I sat down to review this I walked away with a very different impression.  My tasting notes stayed virtually the same, though sometimes it was a bit creamier or funkier, but my overall impression varied wildly.  I had to average out my scores because they varied from 3’s to 7’s.  This was the sort of dram I really need to be in the mood to enjoy— it was weird and strange.  I thought my wife would be really taken with the weird cheesy notes on this, but she found more tart fruits and wanted nothing more to do with it.  As I type this, I can still see her sour disappointed face after she took a first sip.  Our local tasting group has generally loved the younger first fill ex-bourbon Glen Scotia that SMWS has released lately— this one just proved a bit more divisive than usual.

Linkwood 27 Year 1990, Signatory Vintage 30th Anniversary Collection

Linkwood 27 Year 1990, Signatory Vintage 30th Anniversary Collection

Bunnahabhain 10 Year, Signatory Vintage Cask Strength Collection

Bunnahabhain 10 Year, Signatory Vintage Cask Strength Collection