Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Craigellachie 20 Year SMWS 44.125 “El paraiso”

Craigellachie 20 Year SMWS 44.125 “El paraiso”

Whisky : Craigellachie 20 Year SMWS 44.125 “El paraiso”

Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside

ABV : 57.4%

Cask : Refill Oloroso Sherry Butt

Age : 20 Years (Distilled 24 Aug. 1999)

Nose : Rich and spicy.  Heady waves of tobacco, leather, and powdered chocolate.  Sweet molasses and caramelized brown sugar with butter, dried candied fruits, and a delightful mix of fruit punch and sprite which I was told is called “sprunch.”  A few drops of water brought strawberry to the fore along with milk chocolate.

Palate : Thick and viscous, the initial impression was one of honey baked ham skin, pancake syrup, and old oak.  Chocolate emerged with fruits: orange candies, orange cocoa powder dusted truffles, and lemon-lime jellies.  Cinnamon, ginger, and baking spices came on the end while a few drops of water highlighted  tobacco and molasses.

Finish :  Nice and long with notes of citrus oil and chocolate.


Score : 7

Mental Image : Candlelight Soufflé


Notes :  This was a well integrated and mature Craigellachie.  The cask did not overwhelm the meaty-mineral quality of the spirit and a lovely diversity of fruit notes paired well with chocolate and spicy tobacco.  I do think I prefer my scotch a bit younger and punchier, but this was absolutely lovely.  There were no strange off notes on this and the viscosity of the spirit was wonderfully mouth-coating.  I do wish some of those meatier notes that hit right at the outset hung around a bit longer, but waves of sweet spice and caramelized sugars were a crowd pleaser.

Overall a pleasant and well balanced Craigellachie with plenty of nuance.  If I am drinking an older sherried scotch, I want it to be somewhere in the neighborhood of this.



Single Cask Nation 10 Year Blended Malt

Single Cask Nation 10 Year Blended Malt

Stuart’s Old Rare 10 Year Blended Scotch (Sherriff’s Bowmore c. 1945)

Stuart’s Old Rare 10 Year Blended Scotch (Sherriff’s Bowmore c. 1945)