Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Glenburgie 27 Year (1995), Thompson Brothers

Glenburgie 27 Year (1995), Thompson Brothers

Whisky: Glenburgie 27 Year (1995), Thompson Brothers

Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside

ABV: 51.6%

Cask: Refill Hogshead

Age: 27 Years (Distilled 20 June 1995, Bottled 2022)


Nose: Tropical and fruity, milk chocolate, subtle herbal jasmine and tea, citrus.

Palate: Medium-bodied, oily, slightly waxy, tropical fruits, pineapple, herbal tea, honey, earth and moss, touch of bitter tea tannins.

Finish: Long and lingering with vanilla, coconut, and cream.


Score: 8+

Mental Image: Lost on the Fruit Plantation

Narrative & Notes: The aroma was tropical and pleasant, with green mango and hints of papaya on top of citrusy sweet, and slightly herbal shikuwasa. Herbal notes slowly developed with mint, jasmine, and sleepy-time chamomile tea. An underlying chocolatey richness sat mainly in the background while more time brought melon rind forward. Medium-bodied, oily, and a touch waxy, the flavor profile featured a bushel of tropical fruits, herbal teas, and underlying earthy notes. Mango, passionfruit, coconut, and melon arrived with grilled pineapple rings with honey-sweetened mint and chamomile teas following in hot pursuit. Buttery mushrooms came to mind as earth and cream collided, leaving rich forest floor humus and moss behind. A touch of slightly bitter tea tannins provided a lovely contrast at the end. The finish was long and lingering with vanilla, coconut, and cream.

Tropical and sweet with a waxy, oily profile— one could be mistaken for thinking this was a Clynelish, though to be sure, the wax was lighter than the heady paraffin of some similar vintage Clynelish. This Glenburgie featured a beautiful evolution as indistinct tropical fruits gradually took form as mango, pineapple, coconut, and eventually melon. Musty earth and herbs sat further in the background, with a touch of bitter tea contrasting the fruits and cream. The finish was wonderfully long, transitioning from vanilla, almost floral at times, to cream and tropical fruits.

Overall, outstanding. The 1995 vintage for Glenburgie has rightly become well-regarded for these tropical profiles, and there has been an absolute bounty of casks from June 7-20 that year. I have not rated a single one of those casks below a 7, so my expectations are properly high for these malts, yet, twice in recent days, I have encountered examples of the vintage that set a new high bar.

Even more important, the bottle art is superb. I wish I could have a poster of it for my office!

Mannochmore 11 Year (2011), The Single Cask Ltd. Cask 1604A

Mannochmore 11 Year (2011), The Single Cask Ltd. Cask 1604A

Convalmore 40 Year (1977), Cadenhead’s

Convalmore 40 Year (1977), Cadenhead’s