Reviews of scotch and world whiskies by a history professor, his wife, bird, and three cats.

Creag Isle 33 Year Islay Single Malt

Creag Isle 33 Year Islay Single Malt

Whisky: Creag Isle 33 Year Islay Single Malt

Country/Region: Scotland/Islay

ABV: 44.1%

Cask: Cognac Cask Finish

Age: 33 Years


Nose: Oak and mellow florals with a touch of tropical fruit teas and tisanes; antique spice boxes, mellow beachy salt, and florals; morning glories and passion flowers with subtle lavender and orris.

Palate: Light-bodied, mellow maritime brine and dried tropical fruits, floral passion flower and hibiscus with a touch of lavender in the background, heather, old wood and antiques, musty old herbal teas and tobacco, slightly bitter oak and tannins toward the end.

Finish: Long and mellow with gentle florals, tobacco, and a kiss of salt.

Score: 7 (82)


Mental Image: Early Breakfast on the Beach

Narrative & Notes: A mystery malt from Islay! Now, which distillery was famous for its floral, almost perfume, and sometimes soapy whisky in the 1980s?  That is right, I do not believe this could be anything other than Bowmore. It had all the classic floral notions with underlying coastal brine and tobacco— it never crossed over into perfume or soap with its more gentle lavender, but the tropical florals were delightfully familiar. I do not typically get soap from 80s Bowmore, but I can see exactly why those notes strike some people as soap or French perfume.

The aroma was gentle and coastal, with soft tropical vibes running throughout; the palate was much the same, with mellow fruits, florals, and beach notes dominating. A hint of tobacco and tobacco ash hung toward the back with some bitter oak, and a few drops of water brought those straight to the front— I would not advise adding water as I found that anything more than a few drops amplified the latent bitterness, and the whisky became undrinkable.

Overall, a gentle sipper that reminded me of breakfast on cool, damp sand in the morning.

Image Credit: Scotch&Sheen (Check out his awesome review through the link)

Dalwhinnie Distillery Exclusive Batch 1

Dalwhinnie Distillery Exclusive Batch 1

Bowmore 23 Year (1989) Port Cask Matured

Bowmore 23 Year (1989) Port Cask Matured